AI Search Only Feels New If Your SEO Was Shallow via @sejournal, @slobodanmanic
Webinar New AI Search & SEO KPIs: 4 Real Signals AI mentions and citations are benchmarks, not decisions. Get 4 traffic-predictive signals drawn from real bot data across hundreds of sites. Rundown Inside AI Max, PMax & Smart Bidding What to measure, which signals to prioritize, and how to guide automation before AI Max becomes the default. Rundown Why AI volume alone can't deliver personalization Your content architecture may be the real bottleneck. Get the Rundown on what needs to change in your content ops. Webinar SEJ Live: The AI Search Playbook June 17 | AI visibility, social citation signals, and multi-channel attribution — three sessions, live Q&A. Webinar How Freshpet Earned AI's Trust The GEO playbook behind Freshpet's AI Overview citations, plus checks to run on your own brand. Free, live Aug 20. 🔥[Live 8/12 with Loren Baker] Ecommerce SEO: Own your "brand +promo code" search. Two different races, almost the same training. Why arguing over GEO, AEO, or SEO is easier than admitting you skipped the fundamentals. Slobodan Manic 12 seconds ago ⋅ 5 min read Slobodan Manic Host of the No Hacks Podcast and machine-first web optimization consultant at No Hacks Bio Follow Training for AI search and training for Google are two different races with almost the same training. The industry keeps arguing about what to call the new race. That is the wrong argument. Think about a 100m sprinter and a 60m sprinter. Different disciplines, maybe even different winners. But properly training for those two is almost the same. Good SEO practice is what it takes to win in AI search as well, and the fight over whether to call it GEO, AEO, or something else is energy spent on the label instead of the training. I am not the only one making this point. Jono Alderson, a technical SEO consultant who came on the No Hacks podcast, argued that SEO vs. GEO is the wrong question and that AI is not a new discipline. Mordy Oberstein, in conversation with Brent Csutoras, put it as “SEO isn’t dead, strategy is dead.” Ross Hudgens warned against branding yourself as an “SEO/GEO writer.” Three practitioners, within days of each other, arriving at the same place from three directions. When that happens, it usually means the naming fight has become a way to avoid a simpler and less flattering conversation. Everything Google has been suggesting, subtly and less subtly, for more than a decade is the training, and it comes down to common sense and no hacks. Be clear. Have a healthy website and a healthy off-site presence. Let your business drive and power your SEO, not the other way around. None of that was written for AI. It is the unglamorous advice that has been sitting in plain sight for years, the advice that does not sell a course or a new acronym, so most of the industry walked past it in favor of whatever tactic was ranking at the time. A model answering a question about your product is doing a version of what a search engine has always tried to do. It is trying to find the clearest, most consistent, most trustworthy account of who you are and what you sell, and repeat it. A clear website with a coherent off-site presence made that easy for Google, and it makes it easy for a language model. A website built on tricks made it hard for Google, and it makes it hard for a model. The mechanism changed. The thing being rewarded did not. One thing is genuinely new: More focus on off-site, and not in the sense of trying to build backlinks. The non-glamorous activities that never really went mainstream – entity optimization and consistency across every place your brand shows up – matter more now than they used to, because a model assembles its picture of you from everywhere it can read, not from your homepage alone. Whether that feels new to you depends entirely on what your SEO was. If your SEO was content marketing, or publishing shallow content so it temporarily ranks, then yes, a lot of this is new, and it is going to keep feeling new and difficult. The tactics that produced temporary rankings do not produce a trustworthy, consistent entity that a model can rely on. If your SEO was focused on fundamentals, no, this is not new. You have been doing entity work and consistency work the whole time, even if nobody called it that. The people who feel the ground shifting hardest are the ones who skipped the fundamentals the first time. The naming argument is more comfortable than admitting that. So what do you actually do about it? Check whether what you are giving the large language models, and Google’s AI Overviews and AI Mode, would make them hallucinate or pass the wrong information to the user. Every key page on your website, and everything off-site as well. Then prompt the LLMs about your brand and your products. See what they know and where they get their information. Reverse engineer that, instead of focusing on “best X for Y” prompts. That last distinction is the whole move. Most people testing AI visibility type the category prompt, “best CRM for small teams,” and check whether they show up. That tells you where you rank on one phrasing today. Asking the model what it knows about you, and watching which sources it reaches for, tells you what it actually believes and where that belief comes from. One is a ranking check. The other is a map of the exact pages and profiles you need to fix. The map is worth more. And this connects up to something bigger than visibility. The same machine that reads your website to answer a question is the one that will increasingly act on it and buy through it. Getting it to hold an accurate account of you is the groundwork for everything else an agent will try to do with your business. Citations are the smallest part of it. AI search only feels like a new sport to the people who were never really training. Everyone else kept doing the work. Read Full Bio Slobodan Manic Host of the No Hacks Podcast and machine-first web optimization consultant at No Hacks Slobodan “Sani” Manić is a website optimisation consultant with over 15 years of experience helping businesses make their sites faster, ... Learn how to connect search, AI, and PPC into one unstoppable strategy. AI Visibility Rankings Aren’t Stable – New Research Shows It’s Mostly Statistical Noise AI Referrals Are Recreating The Oldest Mistake In Conversion Optimization The Science Of How AI Pays Attention Join 75,000+ Digital Leaders. Learn how to connect search, AI, and PPC into one unstoppable strategy. Learn how to connect search, AI, and PPC into one unstoppable strategy. In a world ruled by algorithms, SEJ brings timely, relevant information for SEOs, marketers, and entrepreneurs to optimize and grow their businesses -- and careers.
Source: Search Engine Journal
This article has been carefully curated and reformatted for educational and informational purposes. Full credit goes to the original publisher.
📚 Visit more helpful articles on Joab Peters Blog
No comments